J. Brent Tartamella - Sales Broker & Rental Agent

J. Brent Tartamella - Sales Broker & Rental Agent

I arrived on Nantucket Sound in 2004 as the inaugural General Manager of The Westmoor Club, where the goal was a world-class, nationally recognized club rooted in tradition and luxury. Over 25 years in the high-end private club profession, including roles at The Country Club, Baltimore Country Club, Philadelphia Cricket Club, Chevy Chase Club, and the Augusta National Masters Tournament, taught me what five-star service really means. I bring that service, a deep island network, local market knowledge, and plain old tenacity to my work at Fisher Real Estate.
I earned my Massachusetts real estate broker license in 2024, and I hold three National Association of Realtors certifications: Accredited Buyer's Representative, Pricing Strategy Advisor, and Resort and Second Home Specialist. I am also a member of REALM, an exclusive global network of top luxury real estate professionals. The trust my clients place in me matters, and I work to exceed their expectations.
Helping families find their perfect Nantucket home has led to more than $180 million in closed transactions. I have been a leading buyer broker on the island by transaction count, and I consistently rank in the top 10% of Premier Agents on Zillow.
I serve on the Cape Cod & Islands Association of Realtors Vacation Rental Committee and the Nantucket High School Council. I am a former President of the New England Club Managers Association and former Board Chair of the Nantucket Lighthouse School. Over my 20-plus years on Nantucket, I have supported many local nonprofits, including the Boys & Girls Club and Community Sailing.
I am married, and my family loves to travel and stay active. When I am not cheering on the kids at their high school games and club events, you will find me tending our family bees, out on a trail with our dog Maple, or, once in a while, enjoying an awesome Nantucket beach.

Homes I've sold

My closed sales by year and price point, pulled from Fisher's Agent Stats. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Recent closings not yet shown in the dashboard: 2 Silver Street ($4,900,000) and 21 Equator ($3,600,000).

Trusted by Our Community

“We loved working with Brent to find a perfect summer rental for our family vacation. Trying to please a big group of people with various ages and preferences was not easy, but Brent was super patient with us and accepted the challenge with enthusiasm. I would highly recommend him!”
Annie Hamnett
Google, rental
“Brent is the best - communicative, honest, so knowledgeable. As an agent myself, I have high standards for what an agent should be and Brent is great. Never pushy and completely trustworthy. If I have any questions about Nantucket he is my first call.”
Amanda Bryan
Google review
"Thanks to Brent, we found the perfect rental quickly and with no hassle."
Julian Cross, rental guest
April 20, 2025
“I can’t say enough about Brent’s knowledge of Nantucket, his attention to detail, and his personal touch. When looking for our home we started with a wide range of options and locations we were considering. Brent listened closely to our likes and dislikes, and quickly honed in on some great homes for us to look at.”
David K.
June 20, 2025
"I can’t say enough about Brent’s knowledge of Nantucket and his attention to detail. He listened closely and guided us through a successful closing."
Aisha Karim
June 21, 2025

Let’s Begin the Conversation

Whether you’re exploring investment opportunities, preparing to sell, or dreaming of life on Nantucket, Brent provides a data-driven, relationship-first approach tailored to your goals.
J. Brent Tartamella
Talk to Brent