Nantucket Real Estate, Refined.

J. Brent Tartamella
Fisher Real Estate

Guiding buyers, sellers, and investors with expertise, integrity, and five-star service.
Pink and gold sunrise sky over a calm bay with sandy dunes and beach grass in the foreground

Curious what your Nantucket home could be worth?

Request a Home Value Snapshot: a data-informed opinion of value built on island-local sales, assessor records and the way Nantucket actually trades. Share a few details and I will follow up personally.

Thank you. I will be in touch personally with your Home Value Snapshot request.
Something went wrong. Please try again, or call 508-901-0191.
A Home Value Snapshot is an opinion of value, not an appraisal. Your details are used only to respond to your request.

Start here

Nantucket, from every angle

Whether you are buying, selling, or planning a stay with seasonal rentals, I bring island-local depth and hospitality-level care to every step. Get oriented with the latest market insights or discover Nantucket, and reach out any time.

Brent’s Track Record

Tangible results reflecting skill, dedication, and expertise

$190M+

in total sales

75+

transactions

113

avg. days on market

95–96%

sale-to-list ratio
J. Brent Tartamella

Meet J. Brent Tartamella

A New England native with a background in hospitality and private club management, Brent has built his real estate career on a foundation of service, discretion, and deep community connections. After moving to Nantucket in 2004 to join the opening team of The Westmoor Club, Brent spent over a decade creating an award-winning private club experience before bringing that same level of excellence to Fisher Real Estate.
‍
Brent has closed over $190M in sales volume on Nantucket, with sales ranging from $373K to $9.85M. His average sale price is about $2.5M, his listings average 113 days on market, and his sales have averaged 95 to 96 percent of the last asking price. Figures as of November 2026.
‍
Brent is known for connecting people to the island—and to each other. His ability to match clients with the right homes, neighborhoods, and resources stems from years of building meaningful relationships across Nantucket’s civic and cultural landscape.

Experience You Can Trust

Residential | Commercial | Land | New Construction
Deep experience across all segments of Nantucket’s market.
Sub-$1M to $15M+ Transactions
A full spectrum of representation, from first-time buyers to legacy estates.
REALM Founding Member
ABR and PSA certified, with island-local depth for buyers and sellers.
Learn More About Brent

Recent Sales and Listings

7 Oak Hollow Lane Nantucket Real Estate
HUMMOCK POND

7 Oak Hollow Lane

3 BEDS | 2 BATHS | 0.46 ACRES
$3,025,000
Sold - Buyer Represented
Real Estate Nantucket Monomoy- 32 Monomoy Road
MONOMOY

Monomoy- 32 Monomoy Road

6 Beds | 5+1 half baths | 0.15 acres
$4,495,000
Sold - Buyer Represented
22 Arlington Street Nantucket Real Estate
TOM NEVERS

22 Arlington Street

2 Beds | 1+1 half baths | 0.23 acres
$1,995,000
Sold - Buyer Represented
2 Silver Street Real Estate Nantucket
TOWN

2 Silver Street

5 Beds | 4+1 half baths | 0.12 acres
$4,295,000
Sold - Seller Represented
View All Properties
[Results Driven]

The Fisher Real Estate Advantage

Fisher Real Estate combines modern marketing strategy with local insight and global reach. Each listing is showcased through professional photography, 3D tours, cinematic video, and data-driven promotion across digital and print channels.
Over 1.1M page views on fishernantucket.com annually
162K+ impressions per property on average via digital ads
Featured across Forbes, Architectural Digest, and Boston Globe
14,000+ newsletter subscribers with a 72% open rate
Fisher Real Estate: Nantucket’s most-viewed Instagram and blog presence
property portfolios office2

Local Presence, Global Reach.

With Fisher’s Main Street visibility and purposefully independent approach, your property is positioned beautifully—reaching the right audience at the right time. Discover your place on Nantucket. Schedule a private consultation.
Schedule a Consultation
Aerial view of Nantucket Island coastline with homes and beach

Market Insight & Integrity

The Nantucket real estate market continues to evolve. Brent leverages Fisher’s proprietary analytics and monthly reporting to help clients navigate pricing, timing, and value trends with clarity and confidence. See the latest figures on the Market Insights page.

Let’s Begin the Conversation

Whether you’re exploring investment opportunities, preparing to sell, or dreaming of life on Nantucket, Brent provides a data-driven, relationship-first approach tailored to your goals.
Brent Tartamella Real Estate Nantucket
Talk to Brent

Trusted by Our Community

“We loved working with Brent to find a perfect summer rental for our family vacation. Trying to please a big group of people with various ages and preferences was not easy, but Brent was super patient with us and accepted the challenge with enthusiasm. I would highly recommend him!”
Annie Hamnett
Google, rental
“Brent is the best - communicative, honest, so knowledgeable. As an agent myself, I have high standards for what an agent should be and Brent is great. Never pushy and completely trustworthy. If I have any questions about Nantucket he is my first call.”
Amanda Bryan
Google review
"Thanks to Brent, we found the perfect rental quickly and with no hassle."
Julian Cross, rental guest
April 20, 2025
“I can’t say enough about Brent’s knowledge of Nantucket, his attention to detail, and his personal touch. When looking for our home we started with a wide range of options and locations we were considering. Brent listened closely to our likes and dislikes, and quickly honed in on some great homes for us to look at.”
David K.
June 20, 2025
"I can’t say enough about Brent’s knowledge of Nantucket and his attention to detail. He listened closely and guided us through a successful closing."
Aisha Karim
June 21, 2025
See and share reviews on Google